Nurses receive feedback on their practice from many sources: from other nurses, colleagues, families, and clients. All of this feedback is valuable, whether it comes verbally or in writing.
Peer feedback can help you be more objective and identify areas in your practice where you can improve. A peer can also help you identify strengths in your practice that you may not be able to identify yourself.
When you renew your registration each year, you’re asked to confirm that you’ve sought peer feedback as part of meeting your quality assurance requirements. While informal peer feedback is valuable, it’s also helpful to solicit feedback in a more deliberate and thoughtful way.
Nurses will complete a more formal feedback process by participating in multisource feedback every five years.
Ask a trusted colleague to sit down with you, and give you feedback on specific areas of your practice. When receiving peer feedback, it can be useful to discuss your
self-assessment (based on the BCCNP Professional Standards for Registered Nurses and Nurse Practitioners), your strengths and those areas you want to improve.
Be creative in choosing a peer to help you assess your practice. Because you are responsible for selecting your peer, you have the opportunity to choose someone whose opinion you respect and whose judgment you trust.
Ideally your peer should be a registered nurse in the same role as you and with whom you work. However, it may be difficult to find a registered nurse in a similar role, in which case you might, for example, choose a registered nurse who has a different role with whom you interact regularly or with whom you have done committee work or who is in the same professional interest group as you. Alternatively you could choose someone you work with who is not a registered nurse, but who you feel is able to comment on your professional practice.
It’s a good idea to start thinking about who will provide peer feedback shortly after you’ve completed your self-assessment. This way, the information will still be fresh in your mind. Many times feedback is received and given in unplanned and spontaneous moments, which can be equally beneficial to your professional development. Regardless of how and when you receive peer feedback, try to view it as a validating and learning experience.
Peer feedback should be a learning and growth opportunity. Next we'll give you some suggestions to help you in asking for feedback from a peer, receiving feedback and giving feedback.
Now that you've assessed your practice and received peer feedback, this is a good time to begin creating a professional development plan. This plan focuses on the learning and development needs you have identified. The skills and knowledge derived from your professional development activities are applied to practice over time, and are an important part of the continuous cycle of quality assurance.
This exchange demonstrates the peer feedback process between registered nurse colleagues on a medical/surgical unit.
Sandy (Registered Nurse): Hi, Jamie. Would you be willing to talk to me about some of my work? Is this a good time to ask you? I think this feedback will take about 20 minutes. (A little nervous and hoping that this is not a good time)
Jamie (Registered Nurse): Okay, but I've never really done this, so I hope it will be helpful. Anyway, I think you are a great nurse and I've always relied on you. Oh no, maybe I'm too biased and I won't be helpful. (She sounds a little ambivalent.)
Sandy: I'm sure you'll only tell me the good stuff. (Both laugh). Well, I brought a guide about feedback. Do you want a few minutes to read it?
Jamie: That would be good. (She reads the points outlined in the guide.) This is helpful. What would you like to talk about? (A little apprehensive.)
Sandy: , I've done some thinking about what I've been doing and feeling at work lately. In the past few months, have you noticed that we are getting more patients with really hard-to-deal-with suicide issues? And those two recent patients . . .
Jamie: They were discharged and in just a few weeks they were back in here again. I'm getting really frustrated.
Sandy: Me too. So I've been thinking about trying to get a better understanding of these patients and how I relate to them. Sometimes I just want to ignore them. Sometimes I'm frustrated by not knowing what to say. Later I just get angry or apathetic. What's the use in putting patients “back together” when they just do it again. (Sandy's thinking about Standard 2: Knowledge-based practice, and Standard 3: Client-focused provision of service))
Jamie: I think you're doing okay. We all have problems with giving these patients care.
Sandy: I know. In doing this self-assessment, I wanted to be open and figure out if I, or staff on the unit, could be doing something else.
Jamie: I can see why, especially when you seem to get most of these patients. I think you're doing well with this group. I remember how frustrated you got when that really difficult patient started yelling and going AWOL. You became even more frustrated and annoyed because we couldn't get discharge planning organized and then the patient . . . Even if it was frustrating, I still think you are doing a great job in these very tough situations.
Sandy: Thanks. That's good to hear. I think it might be a good idea to get a mental health nurse expert to come to the unit and review or talk about suicide to get a better understanding of how to relate, communicate and respond to difficult patients. I'd also like to get an update on suicide assessments, and maybe some motivational communication techniques. I hear these are good to use. We also need to identify good places to refer these patients to.
Jamie: I think I may need this too. Maybe we can try to organize it for our group. I'm getting ahead of myself. First, let's talk to the group and then see what would work for them. (They talk some more and then . . .
Sandy: I thought this feedback was going to be hard to ask for and get.
Jamie: I hope I was helpful.
Sandy: Yes, you did very well Jamie. I really didn't know that you thought I was handling it well. Thanks.
This conversation illustrates a registered nurse asking for and receiving feedback from a colleague who is not a registered nurse.
BJ (registered nurse who works alone in the community): I've done my self-assessment and want to go over it with you. It will take some time, about 20 to 30 minutes. What do you think Kellie?
Kellie (Social Worker): Why me? What do you mean by "self-assessment"? Doesn't your manager have to do your performance evaluations?
BJ: We work together and I trust your opinions even though we may argue and differ sometimes. (Laughter) It's okay, I'll tell you if you're being too tough on me. In nursing, we have to do a self-assessment and get peer feedback, identify some professional development needs and activities and look at how these actions influence our prac- tice. We do the self-assessment as a professional development exercise and as part of our annual registration renewal process. Performance appraisals are job-related and are done by someone in supervisory, management or administrative roles. This is very personal and it's a component of my registration renewal each year.
Kellie: Okay, what do I do?
BJ: To start, would you to look over the peer feedback points in this guide? (Kellie spends some time doing this). I identified three major areas I want to focus on. I think I could do a better job in communicating and sharing information with the community. I set up programs, but few people seem to respond and come. I sometimes feel like I'm up against the wall. What do you think? I know the programs are good. If only people came out to them.
Kellie: You're right, your programs are great. You are so careful when developing them. You spend a lot on them and use excellentresources. I find your work really helpful. I also agree that people in the community don't come. But why? Can I ask you some more questions? (A "yes" nod from BJ) How do you plan and get community participation? You may need to look at this part of your program preparations. Community participation and development is a large part of program development and delivery. I'm not sure if you're doing enough of this up front work. (BJ looks uncomfortable and is quiet.) Is this okay feedback?
BJ: Yes, it is. So you think up front work? Maybe this is a new challenge for me. What is my relationship with this community? How do I get the community involved? I had only a couple of courses in community development in school and that was a while ago. I may need to look into this area. This is a different type of community than where I worked in before. Do you think you can guide me in some of these attempts?
Kellie: Sure. (They continue to discuss the issues and then later . . .)
BJ: Peer feedback is a good thing to do. You were very helpful and honest. Thanks Kellie!
Kellie: After all that, how do you think I'm doing? I think you should give me some feedback too.
BJ: Good, I thought you'd never ask. (Laughter) You have to be more specific with what you want feedback on. Can you tell me about social workers' practice standards?
The following is an exchange among peers at a staff meeting/workshop to look at professional development or education activities for the following year. The staff have previously decided to use the personal practice review requirements to develop learning resources. The clinician receives spontaneous feedback from a group of colleagues and is able to respond to that feedback, recognizing that feedback is an ongoing cyclical process.
Mandeep (Clinician): Last year for our ongoing clinical updates and education days, we looked at what kinds of professional development we wanted. We took time to do our self-assessments and talk about our practice and some of our issues on the unit. So, last year, besides the regular and mandatory clinical updates like central lines and TPN, we added two workshops on pacemakers and balloon pumps. How was that?
Jane (Staff RN): I don’t know what it was like for anyone else, but I went to the session and didn’t have to use that information for about three months and I forgot it all by then. Thank goodness Anne was here to help me. What would happen if she wasn’t around? (Jane looks angry.)
Mandeep: Are you saying we shouldn’t have these sessions?
Dianne (Staff RN): No, but we need someone or something else at the time. I wouldn’t feel competent if I couldn’t practice and keep up.
Mandeep: You know, this is really good feedback for me. So what you are telling me is that I’ve got to provide a number of different ways in which you can easily get the information?
Anne (Staff RN): Yes, like a manual or a unit specific clinical data resource that we can easily access and print off the computer and bring to the bedside. But when can it be done? And do we all need an inservice on how to use the Intranet? My skills are okay, but some staff will need an inservice.
Mandeep: You need this soon, right? A number of the procedures are already available online. Maybe I should have these two procedures put online too and get access for the staff as soon as possible. What kind of schedule do you think we should develop? What else do you think might be of help? (They all consider this, then later...)
Mandeep: Has everyone reviewed your self-assessment? Last year we were nervous and apprehensive about giving and getting peer feedback. You had asked that this year we first talk about feedback. I will put the peer feedback pointers on the overhead so we can review them.
The group talks over the feedback process and this leads to a discussion on how staff members relate to each other, the changes on the unit and the education needs of the staff. The conversation continues while Mandeep makes notes on the flip chart to help identify some of the professional development activities for the next few months.
How would you rate the information on this page?
Thank you. Your feedback has been submitted.